When the time comes to part with your prized rare vinyl records, the selling process should be as exceptional as the records themselves. You deserve a hassle-free experience that guarantees a fair and rewarding price. Entrusting your rare vinyl to a reputable local record store like Record Head is the smartest choice.

At Record Head, we confidently stand as the best place to sell rare vinyl records in Milwaukee. We understand the unique value and significance of your collection.

Rare vinyl record tips
Masked group wave lines
Record wave

What Makes a Vinyl Record Rare?

Several characteristics can elevate a vinyl record from common to coveted. Recognizing these factors is key to understanding its potential value:

  • First and early pressings: Often released in limited quantities, especially for burgeoning artists, these initial runs can become highly sought-after collector’s items if the artist or album achieves widespread acclaim.

  • Deleted or out-of-print titles: Records that have been removed from a label’s catalog or whose production was halted due to legal issues or other circumstances naturally become scarcer and more valuable over time.

  • Signed by the artist: A record personally signed by the artist adds an undeniable layer of uniqueness and sentimental value, significantly increasing its rarity and market price compared to an unsigned copy.

  • Color variants and limited editions: Many special releases feature vinyl pressed in unique colors or patterns, distinguishing them from standard black editions. These visually distinct versions are often produced in smaller batches, making them highly desirable.

  • Exclusive bonus material: Records that include unreleased tracks, unique commentary, alternative takes or other content not found on standard releases are particularly appealing to collectors.

  • Age and condition: As records accumulate over the years, many become lost, damaged or simply fall out of circulation. Older records that have been meticulously preserved and remain in excellent condition are often considerably more valuable.

How We Evaluate Rare Records

Rare or unique records must be assessed based on their:

  • Vinyl and cover condition
  • Pressing details
  • Label variations
  • Matric numbers
  • Current market demand

Without taking all of these factors into account, any financial assessment of your record would be based at least partially on guesswork. At Record Head, we can make you a fair offer for your rare vinyl records that’s based on their true market value.

Why Sell Your Rare Vinyl Records to Record Head

Besides our careful and accurate analysis of your record, we make selling your rare records much easier and faster than selling online. Online selling often involves a lengthy, uncertain waiting game for the right buyer, coupled with potential listing fees and shipping costs. Plus, without expert knowledge, you risk underpricing your valuable records.

At Record Head, we eliminate these challenges. We’ve been buying and selling rare vinyl since its initial boom, leveraging over five decades of experience to accurately determine the true value of your records. Our long-standing reputation for fair prices and transparency means you can trust us to provide a competitive and genuine offer for your collection. 

dark waveline
Record Head text location background

Visit Record Head in Person Today

Our expert team is eager to evaluate your record and discuss its sale. While you’re here, you’ll also have the perfect opportunity to explore our extensive collection of media and electronics.

Prefer to chat first? Give us a call at 414-453-3900 to discuss your rare vinyl before your visit. We look forward to seeing you!

Store Hours

  • Sunday: 9:30am -6pm
  • Monday – Thursdays: 9:30am -7pm
  • Fridays: Summer 9:30am -6pm  •  Winter 9:30am -4pm
  • Saturday: CLOSED

Our Location

  • Record Head: 7045 W Greenfield Ave, West Allis, Wl 53214
  • Phone: (414) 453-3900
    Fax:
  • Follow Us: